A salary, a manager title, a 1099, a day rate, or an agreement to work for straight time does not by itself take away the right to overtime under the federal overtime law, the Fair Labor Standards Act. A private employer also cannot give time off in place of overtime pay, and it cannot refuse to pay for overtime work that it allowed.

Many people who call me have heard something about the overtime law that is wrong. Some heard it from an employer, and some heard it from a co-worker. Each statement below is false as a general rule. Whether a particular worker is owed overtime depends on the facts of the job.

"I am paid a salary, so I do not get overtime." FALSE

This is the misunderstanding I hear most often. A salary alone does not take away the right to overtime. The law calls an employee who has no right to overtime "exempt," and it calls the rules that take away the right "exemptions." For the most common exemptions, the employer must prove each of the following.

  1. The employer paid you on a salary basis. That means you received a set amount each pay period, which could be all or part of your pay, and except in a few situations the regulation lists, that amount did not go down because you worked fewer hours or because the quality or amount of your work changed (29 C.F.R. § 541.602), AND
  2. The salary was large enough, and the employer did not reduce it. The salary must be at least $684 per week, which is $35,568 per year (29 C.F.R. § 541.600). If the employer had a practice of reducing your salary when you missed part of a day or when the employer had no work for you, the employer can lose the exemption for the period when it made those deductions (29 C.F.R. § 541.603), AND
  3. Your duties fit an exemption. The main exemptions cover executive, administrative, and professional employees. Each one has its own list of required duties, and the question is what your primary duty was, which means the main or most important work you performed (29 C.F.R. § 541.700).

If the employer does not prove all 3 elements, that exemption does not apply. Unless another exemption applies, the employer owes overtime for the hours you worked over 40 in a week.

"My title is manager, so I am exempt." FALSE

A job title does not make an employee exempt. The regulation says, "A job title alone is insufficient to establish the exempt status of an employee" (29 C.F.R. § 541.2). Whether you are exempt depends upon what you actually do, not your title, and as mentioned above, you must be paid a salary of at least $684 per week.

"I get a 1099, or I was told I am an independent contractor, so I am not entitled to overtime." FALSE

A court does not rely on the tax form or on a contract that calls you an independent contractor. In fact, I typically give independent contractor agreements little weight, if any. Courts look at the working relationship between the employer and the worker. They ask whether you depended on the company for your income or whether you operated a business of your own. A worker who is an employee under that test, and who is not exempt, has the right to overtime, whatever the paperwork says.

"I agreed to straight time, or I agreed I would not get overtime, so I cannot ask for overtime now." FALSE

An employee cannot agree in advance to give up the right to overtime. If you agreed to work for your regular rate for all hours worked, or for a flat amount, the employer still owes the overtime premium, which is the additional half of the regular rate, for the hours over 40. A settlement that you signed after you did the work, to resolve a real dispute about the hours you worked, is a different question, and it may be binding.

"I am paid by the day, so overtime does not apply." FALSE

Being paid by the day does not take away the right to overtime. If you are paid only a day rate, and the day rate does not depend on how many hours you work, the regulation tells the employer to add up the day-rate pay for the week and divide it by the hours you worked that week. The result is your regular rate. The employer then owes an extra half of that rate for each hour over 40, in addition to the day-rate pay (29 C.F.R. § 778.112).

"My employer can give me time off instead of overtime pay." FALSE

A private employer must pay overtime in wages. The federal law allows compensatory time off instead of overtime pay for employees of state and local governments, under conditions the statute sets. It does not allow that practice for private employers (29 U.S.C. § 207(o)).

"The company did not approve the overtime, so it does not have to pay for it." FALSE

If the employer knew or had reason to believe that you were working, the time counts as work time, even when no one asked you to work it (29 C.F.R. § 785.11). An employer that does not want the work performed must stop it. A rule against unapproved overtime does not excuse the employer from paying for work it allowed (29 C.F.R. § 785.13).


If one of these describes your job and you want to know whether the law requires your employer to pay you overtime, call me at (512) 799-2048 for a free consultation.